How the letters are used
S is an environmental sign with a vague or easy-to-skip fix. A is an explicit creature or on-screen warning. B is a door or appliance state. C is a visible care task. Use it as a last look before sleep, then trust the badge you receive.
S tier
Player decision Close every blind before bed. Do not walk the darkness as if you were collecting mail.
Player decision Walk the windows and close the curtains on the face you find.
Player decision If a familiar object has moved, stop and inspect it before sleep.
Player decision Treat the breathing as a cue to change the lights in that room before bed, then see which badge you get.
A tier
Player decision Get away from the door, enter a back room, and close that door.
Player decision Photograph him with the phone so he disappears. Leaving him and sleeping is Peek a Boo.
Player decision Stay out of the hallway until the knocking stops. Do not let her in.
Player decision Flush it before bed. Leaving it is Down the Drain.
Player decision Turn the TV on to put it to sleep. If it reaches the end of the street, the reported result is Catzilla.
Player decision Look at the cat for a few seconds and confirm the head is gone before sleep.
B tier
Player decision Shut it so Whiskers cannot leave, then lock it so nobody gets in.
Player decision Take the microwave dinner and close the door before bed.
Player decision Leave the stove off even though you heat dinner in the microwave.
Player decision Use it to stop the street creature, then turn it off before bed.
C tier
Player decision Finish all three on a survival night. Skip exactly one when you are hunting Unfinished Business, Uh oh Stinky, or Ancy.